The controversy arising from the dispute concerning the lack of technical requirements regarding the noble title of the past Grand Master Pierre Plantard, although appearing from the outside as an inconsistency, in reality this proves nothing other than the essential prerogative of the Priory of Sion it is not to be sought in historical vicissitudes, but rather in being a coherent initiatory system, composed of interdependent symbols and allegories, which does not need to be essentially real, to be true.
In this case, it is necessary to see what is the truth that wants to be expressed, through something that cannot be objectively considered as completely adherent to reality.
To do this, one has to start from the fact that Pierre Pantard, has Saint-Clair as last name, then Plantard de Saint-Clair, and this can also be obtained from personal documents, including the death certificate. In addition to this, it should be said that Plantard's surname is also a noble family's and that our tradition always tells us that the Plantard surname comes from a nickname given to Sigebert IV Plant-Ard "Rejeton" Ardent Prince - Ermite Comte de Rhédae, who in 681 inherited from his uncle the titles of Count di Rhédae and Duke of Razès.
With Sigebert IV° was originated the name Plantard from the "Plant-Ard" nickname, approached next to the name of the noble, which was precisely called Sigebert IV° "Plant-Ard"or "dit le Plantard"; this name, in reality concealed two hidden meanings, which refers to a "plant" (Plant) which has robust origins, understood as deep or distant, so, "Ard"; with deep can be an allusion to a profound knowledge with "deep roots", at the same time, the allusion may refer also to the antiquity of the roots understood as a family of ancient origin or referring to the antiquity of the repository of knowledge, or all those meanings together.
To conclude this bracket, it is good to point out that we believe in a certain continuity between the noble family Plantard, the Saint-Clair family, and Pierre Plantard de Saint-Clair, even if we admit that the actual requirements for Pierre Plantard de Saint-Clair to legally be considered noble, are uncertain with the present documentation, and although there are documents where Pierre Plantard de Saint-Clair is actually reported as "Comte de Saint-Clair and Comte de Rhédae", we admit that they are not sufficient to prove that he has been in possession of the actual legal requirements.
It is also appropriate to remember that in modern times this is part of the "trademark" and the charm of the Priory of Sion: an important right that exists in spite of the rule.
This is explained by the fact that this is an esoteric field, where value lies in the initiatory deposit and knowledge, things that have no relation to the technicalities of noble law.
Pierre Plantard has sought several times to clarify this difference as to the type of legitimacy he claims, but has continued to be misunderstood by many to this day.
Returning to Saint Clair, they were originally a noble French family, and their name derives from Sancto Claro, the name of a place in the French Normandy Duchy of which they originate; later moved to Scotland, the family name, from Saint-Clair, will become Sinclair, since the end of the 16th century, then a branch of the Sinclair Clan, were exactly the Sinclair of Roslin, the baronate where was erected the famous Chapel of Rosslyn, which is notoriously symbolic of Templar and Masonic influence, traditions deeply linked to the history and the initiatory deposit of the Priory of Sion.
Our oral tradition connects the Saint-Clair lineage to the Merovingian Dynasty, which we consider to be the holders of the primordial tradition that has come to us from Babylon and again from Atlantis, through them, in addition of being the dynasty that actually gave origin to the France, ferrying it out of the barbarian age.
The Merovingians are linked to the Priory of Sion, since it is their ancestral tradition that the Order inherited, and Pierre Plantard de Saint-Clair, was also the heir of that initiatory deposit through their transmission, as well as being heir of his merovingian origins, though surely very diluted, through the Saint-Clair.
The intent of the past Grand Master of the Priory of Sion, Pierre Plantard de Saint-Clair, was therefore only to emphasize a myth with the aim of represent something true.
For all these reasons, we believe legitimate Pierre Plantard de Saint-Clair's nobility and initiatory legacy, as we think that besides being connected to merovingian ancestors, it was at the same time one among their descendants to have simultaneously inherited the Scepter of Sion.
The initiatory deposit of the Order, in the application through the personal path, is classified through the Degrees, but it is not limited to being a metaphysical, ecstatic or symbolic esotericism, even if it encompasses all these phases, but aims to be a form of operational esotericism.